Axis Bank vs ICICI Bank: Analysis of Private Sector Banks

I am sure that you all have heard about Axis bank vs ICICI bank, but have you ever thought which of these banks is doing better? 

Prepare for a financial showdown as we dissect these two titans of the private banking sector. Uncover the strengths, weaknesses, and strategies shaping India’s banking landscape.

Axis Bank – An Overview 

One of India’s top three banks, Axis Bank, was initially established as UTI Bank by a joint venture between the Life Insurance Corporation of India, the Government of India, and other business houses.

UTI Bank’s operations started in the year 1994 when it opened its first branch in Ahmedabad, Gujrat. By the mid of 2007, UTI bank was renamed to “Axis Bank” and Shikha Sharma was appointed as the MD and CEO. It soon became a well-established and recognised bank in the Indian Banking sector. This was a turning point in the history of Axis Bank because it became an aggressive player, and focused on branch expansion and innovation. Additionally, Axis Bank consistently made an effort to diversify its product portfolio.  

At present, Axis Bank has a total of over 4,800 branches and 13,000 ATMs throughout India. The headquarters of Axis Bank is located in Mumbai. The bank is advancing to new heights with Mr Amitabh Chaudhary as its MD and CEO.

The bank now offers a variety of financial products, including credit cards, savings accounts, current accounts, brokerage facilities, and retail banking.

ICICI Bank – An Overview 

ICICI Banks stands for Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India and is regarded as India’s second-largest private sector bank. Through a joint venture with other industrial houses, the World Bank and the government of India initiated the establishment of ICICI in 1955 as a part of their initiative to accelerate the economy’s industrial growth by providing them with long and medium-term growth.

In October 2001, the directors of ICICI and ICICI Bank approved the merger of its subsidiary businesses such as ICICI Personal Finance Limited, and ICICI Capital Services Limited with ICICI Bank. The directors of ICICI and ICICI Bank granted their approval for the merger of their subsidiary businesses, such as ICICI Personal Finance Limited, and ICICI Capital Services Limited into ICICI Bank in October 2001. In 2002, the merger proposal was completed and sanctioned by the RBI. Subsequently, all the branches of ICICI were merged into one entity referred to as ICICI Bank.

At present, ICICI bank has more than 5,500 branches across India, as well as more than 13,200 ATMs.

ICICI became the first Indian company and Asian bank other than Japanese Banks to be listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). ICICI Bank is currently under Mr. Sandeep Bakshi’s guidance.

Axis Bank vs ICICI Bank Comparative Analysis 

Before deciding which private bank is best for you, we will provide you with a comparison between Axis and ICICI Bank.

Market Capitalization

Axis Bank – 3,28,352 Crores (As of 7th Feb 2024)

ICICI Bank – 7,15,780 Crores (As of 7th Feb 2024)

From the figures above we can say that ICICI Bank has a higher market capitalization than Axis Bank.

These two players dominate the Bank nifty index as ICICI Bank has a weightage of 24.45% and Axis Bank has a weightage of 10.05%.

Share Price

Axis Bank – 1063 (As of 7th Feb 2024)

ICICI Bank – 1019 (As of 7th Feb 2024)

Axis Bank vs ICICI Bank Financial Statement Analysis

Before we move on, let’s start by looking at the financial statements of Axis Bank and ICICI Bank in a comparative manner.

1. Total Income – Axis Bank’s total income was Rs 35,136 crores, while ICICI Bank’s total income is about Rs. 59,479 crores, showcasing a year-on-year growth rate of around 27% for both companies. 
2. Net Profit – The net profit of Axis Bank is Rs. 6,493 crores, while ICICI Bank has a net profit of around 11,255 crores, depicting a YoY growth rate of -23.4% and 33.64% respectively. 
3. Total Assets – The total assets of Axis Bank are worth approximately Rs. 1,344,417 crores, while the total assets of ICICI Bank are valued at approximately Rs. 19,58,490 crores while having a YoY growth rate of 12.45% and 11.74% respectively. 
4. Total Deposits  – Axis Bank holds around 9,45,824 crores in deposits, while ICICI Bank holds Rs.12,10,832 crores. The YoY growth rate stood at 15.2% and 11%. 
5. Net NPA – The Net NPA of Axis Bank was 0.39% in FY23 from 0.73% in FY22, whereas the Net NPA of ICICI Bank was 0.51% in FY23 from 0.81% in FY22.

(The above mentioned figures are as of March 2023)

Key Ratios

Now that we have compared financial statements, we can move on to the key ratios of both Axis Bank and ICICI Bank.

1. TTM PE Ratio – PE ratio refers to the price-to-earning ratio of a company, which tells whether the company stock is overvalued or undervalued. In terms of Trailing Twelve Months (TTM) PE ratio, Axis Bank has a PE ratio of 24.46, whereas ICICI Bank has a PE ratio of 16.88.

2. CASA (Current Account and Savings Account) – CASA refers to the ratio of the total amount deposited by the customer into their savings and current accounts compared to the total amount deposited in the bank. Axis Bank had a CASA ratio of 47.12% in FY23 and 44.96% in FY22, and ICICI Bank had a CASA ratio of 45.47% in FY23 and 48.60% in FY22.

Current and savings accounts constitute a substantial portion of both ICICI and Axis Bank’s total deposits. This indicates that the banks are able to get access to cheaper sources of funds. But, while Axis bank managed to increase its CASA ratio, ICICI’s ratio decreased. 

3. Net Interest Margin – The Net Interest Margin (NIM) is the distinction between the income generated by banks from interest earned and interest payout to deposit providers.

Axis Bank had a net interest margin of 3.27 in FY23 from 2.83 in FY22, whereas ICICI Bank had a net interest margin of 3.60 in FY23 from 3.09 in FY22.

4. Operating Profit Margin

The operating profit margin is determined by dividing the bank’s operating profit by its operating earnings. If the operating profit margin is higher, the bank is better able to manage its operations. 

Axis Bank has a negative operating profit margin of -8.98%, while ICICI Bank has a negative operating profit margin of -25.31%. 

(The above mentioned ratios are as of March 2023)

Conclusion

Although ICICI Bank has a higher net interest margin than Axis Bank, the operating profit margin of ICICI Bank is less than Axis Bank. However, these are not the sole factors that one should consider before investing in these banks. Despite the strong branch network and fundamentals of these banks, it is important to consider your risk appetite and investment horizon before making any investment decision.

FAQs