What is the Difference Between CDSL and NSDL?

CDSL and NSDL are the two depositories in India that are responsible for holding and keeping a record of securities held in electronic form. NSDL was established in 1996 and primarily deals with the National Stock Exchange (NSE). CDSL was founded in 1999  and has the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) as its promoter. Understanding the key difference between CDSL and NSDL will help investors navigate India’s financial markets better.

In this blog, we will give you an overview of the NSDL and CDSL and the differences between them. Moreover, we will explain how they work and the services they provide.

What is NSDL?

The full form of NSDL is National Securities Depository Limited is one of the two central depositories in India. It was established in 1996. NSDL plays a major role in the Indian financial market by facilitating the dematerialization of securities and enabling the shift from physical share certificates to electronic format. 

NSDL is closely associated with the National Stock Exchange (NSE), one of India’s leading stock exchanges. As of September 2024, the demat accounts at NSDL held securities worth INR 506.11 lakh crores and has a network of 289 depository participants. NSDL has over 3.8 crore demat accounts and has added an average of 5,449 demat accounts per day since its inception. The headquarters of the organization is in Mumbai.

What is CDSL?

CDSL’s full form is Central Depository Services Limited. It is one of India’s two primary securities depositories and was established in 1999. CDSL’s core purpose is to facilitate the dematerialization of physical certificates and store them in electronic format, ensuring a more secure and efficient method of handling the securities transactions. 

CDSL works closely with the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), which is one of the major stock exchanges in India, offering the services to stockbrokers and investors through its network of depository participants (DPs). As of 30 September 2024, CDSL has over 13.7 crore demat accounts with more than INR 78.26 lakh crores worth of securities.

Both depositories serve the sаme purpose but cater to different stock exchanges. When it comes to CDSL vs NSDL, while both the depositories offer similar services, NSDL is the older institution, and it was the first to introduce the concept of dematerialization in India.

Difference Between NSDL and CDSL

Registration of DPs with NSDL and CDSL

Depository Participants (DPs) serve as intermediaries between the depositories—NSDL (National Securities Depository Limited) and CDSL (Central Depository Services Limited) and investors, helping them open and manage the demat accounts online for storing securities in electronic format. The process of registering as a DP with NSDL and CDSL follows the strict regulatory guidelines to ensure security and transparency in the Indian financial market.

DP Registration with NSDL

The entity must comply with the regulations set by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and also the NSDL’s internal standards to register as a DP with NSDL. Only eligible organizations such as banks, financial institutions and brokerage firms are allowed to apply for DP registration.

• Application Process: The organization submits a formal application to NSDL with every detail related to legal structure and financial health as per the SEBI norms. The documents include Form E, board resolution, net worth certificate, Form A and other details related to business history, promoter backgrounds, etc. 

• Verification and Compliance: NSDL’s member committee evaluates the application and approves it if the applicant has fulfilled all the requirements.

• Hardware Requirements: Upon approval, the applicant buys the necessary hardware mentioned under the “Specifications & Investments” section of the NSDL. 
• Training and Agreement: NSDL ensures that the DP is technically equipped to handle investor accounts with proper training in the NSDL’s systems. NSDL organizes a training program for the staff members of the applicant to train them. The applicant and NSDL sign an agreement after the fee payment, and the applicant can now start operation as a DP. 

DP Registration with CDSL

The process for registering a DP with CDSL is similar as per the SEBI’s guidelines and CDSL’s requirements:

• Application Submission: The applicant submits documents related to experience, background, annual reports, etc. The applicant is required to submit the documents in the checklist and format set by the SEBI.

• Due Diligence: CDSL conducts a thorough review of the applicant’s infrastructure, financial stability, and SEBI compliance.

• Hardware Requirements: Once approved, the applicant should buy computer hardware and establish connectivity with CDSL. 

• Training and Agreement: CDSL provides technical support and training to ensure that the DP can operate efficiently within its depository framework. The applicant must assign at least two trained staff members to attend a five-day training program organized by the CDSL. After the approval from SEBI, an agreement is signed between the CDSL and the applicant, allowing the applicant to begin operations as a DP of CDSL.

How do Depositories Work?

Depositories play a crucial role in the functioning of the financial markets by facilitating the electronic holding and transfer of securities. The core functions of Depositories are:

• Dematerialization: Depositories convert physical securities such as shares into electronic form. This process is known as dematerialization. Investors can open a demat account with a CDSL or NSDL with the help of a Depository Participant (DP) to hold securities in electronic format. 

• Safekeeping: Once securities are dematerialized they are stored electronically in the investor’s demat account. The depository ensures the security of electronic records and protects investors from risks like loss, theft or forgery associated with physical certificates.

• Settlement of Transactions: When an investor buys or sells securities, the depository facilitates the transfer of ownership. Upon the execution of a transaction, the depository updates its records to reflect the change in ownership.

Services Offered by NSDL and CDSL

Both NSDL and CDSL play vital roles in the Indian financial market, offering a range of services that facilitate the electronic storage of securities. The services provided by CDSL and NSDL are:

• Dematerialization: NSDL and CDSL enable investors to convert physical securities into electronic form, allowing for safer and more efficient trading.

• E-Voting Services and Corporate Actions Processing: Both depositories provide E-voting services to shareholders. Depositories also share the beneficiary’s information with the issuer and Registrar and Transfer Agents (RTA) to help them process corporate actions like bonus issues and dividends.

• Settlement Services: NSDL and CDSL facilitate the smooth settlement of trades executed on stock exchanges by updating the ownership records promptly.

CDSL Vs NSDL – Which is Better?

When it comes to choosing between CDSL (Central Depository Services Limited) and NSDL (National Securities Depository Limited), there’s not much difference as both the depositories offer similar services, essential for participating in the financial markets in India. But there are some factors that can help you in deciding between CDSL and NSDL, as listed below:

• Market Share: NSDL was established in 1996 with a focus on providing dematerialization services to institutional investors. It has a larger market share in terms of the value of securities held in the NSDL demat accounts and is primarily linked to the National Stock Exchange (NSE). On the other hand, CDSL is primarily involved with the BSE, has a more extensive network of Depository Participants (DPs) and has a higher number of demat accounts.

• Service Offerings: Both depositories provide similar core services including the dematerialization and settlement of transactions, with the corporate actions and e-voting. However, the NSDL is often preferred by institutional investors due to its ability to handle high-volume trades. In contrast, the CDSL has strong links with popular discount brokers due to which it has more demat accounts. Discount brokers are popular among retail investors due to lower AMC compared to full-service brokers, which makes CDSL the default option for a lot of retail investors.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the choice between CDSL and NSDL depends on individual preferences and requirements. For institutional investors seeking advanced infrastructure to execute high-volume transactions, NSDL may be the better option. On the other hand, CDSL is strongly associated with discount brokers, which makes it the depository for many retail investors. Evaluating the specific needs and costs will guide investors in making the best decision. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)