Tax on Commodity Trading in India

With the introduction of commodity transaction tax (CTT), commodity trading in India slowly turned a new page, altering how investors speculate in the market. Not only has this tax made trading more expensive, but the nature of the markets has also shifted as well. 

So, let’s have a look at the effects taxation on commodity trading has on your trading strategy and financial planning.

Effects of Trading Costs and Market Behavior

The Commodity Transaction Tax (CTT) in India was introduced on 1 July 2013. This tax on commodity trading was announced during the Budget 2013 by the former Finance Minister P. Chidambaram. This levy is a carbon copy of the Securities Transaction Tax on equities and is created to ensure that there is equality in taxation across different financial securities. You have to pay these charges as a seller of the non-agricultural commodity derivatives.

Currently, the CTT rate is 0.01%, a seemingly tiny amount. But when trading in high volumes, these small percentages can account for huge amounts. The result of this increase in trading costs has been a tangible impact on the behavior of market participants. Volumes have been dipping noticeably among high-frequency traders and speculators who trade on small profit margins and rely on sheer trading volume.

Now, each trade costs more, and traders are carrying out fewer but more incisive trades. If this shift continues, it could lead to a less liquid market, which may, in turn, reduce the popularity of commodities trading.

• Different opinions have emerged about the impact of the CTT on the efficiency of the market. Critics say it may keep small investors and hedgers away from the market, thus upsetting the proper functioning of the market.
  
• A few traders have shifted to agricultural commodities that are outside the ambit of CTT. This shift is in line with other emerging trends in trading patterns and calls for a better analysis of the effects of taxes on the trading behavior of market participants.

Read Also: How to Trade in the Commodity Market?

Taxation Strategy for Profits

The CTT is not the only commodity trading income tax. You also need to know how your profits and losses are taxed. Profits from buying and selling derivative contracts of a particular commodity are classified as business income in India, not as capital gains under the Income Tax Act. The classification carries strategic implications. If your commodity trading profits are speculative (i.e., cash-settled derivatives) in nature, then these profits can only be offset against speculative losses. You can’t offset these losses against income from non-speculative trading activities, which involve the delivery of physical commodities at the expiration of the derivatives contract.

However, non-speculative trading involving the actual delivery of commodities is more flexible. In this case, you can offset speculative and non-speculative profits with losses, offering greater scope for tax planning while trading commodities. Speculative business losses can be carried forward for 4 years, while other non-speculative losses can be carried forward to set off future speculative and non-speculative gains for 8 years.

Traders playing the long game can use these rules to minimize their commodity trading income tax liability over time. In the event of a year with more losses than gains, this strategy can save you a lot of tax. This only works if traders keep detailed records of their transactions and keep them separate from speculative and non-speculative activities. Beyond aiding tax planning, this also ensures compliance with tax regulations, avoiding penalties for misrepresentation or oversight.

Regulatory and Fiscal Policy Implications

The use of CTT was done in line with a fiscal approach concerning taxation of commodity transactions. The tax was launched in 2013 with the view to reduce speculation and, at the same time, increase government revenues. 

However, the policy has attracted criticism. Critics argue that it hurts the competitiveness of Indian commodity exchanges against global counterparts. 

This is particularly important given that, unlike many other markets around the world, India levies a higher transactional cost. The trading volumes have been significantly affected by the commodity trading income tax.

• Market research indicates that India’s commodity trading volume lowered after 2013, which could be a result of CTT. There is still controversy over the issue of reconsidering or eliminating the CTT.
• Advocates of CTT see it as contributing both to market stability and revenue, while opponents look at its detrimental effect on efficient market functioning. To investors and brokers, it is vital to keep up with regulatory changes.
• This means that to adapt to current policies, it is not only necessary to respond to change but, more importantly, to anticipate how fiscal change might impact existing trading strategies and the market.

Market regulations compel market players to consider various techniques and strategies in the management of risk and taxation to break even and avoid violation of the law.

Read Also: What is Commodity Market in India?

Conclusion

The Indian commodity trading landscape witnessed a significant reduction in trading volumes due to the implementation of CTT in 2013. Moreover, the classification of gains and losses as speculative and non-speculative further complicates the taxation procedure. 

Understanding the taxation treatment of trading profits and losses enables traders to better handle capital gain tax on commodity trading by updating their trading strategies for managing profits and losses. However, it is necessary to consult a financial advisor before trading in commodities.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)